Start with free nonprofit credit counseling. A certified counselor will review your whole budget and explain your options, including a debt management plan (DMP), at no cost or low cost before you commit to anything. Debt settlement is a last resort before bankruptcy. It can damage your credit, creditors can still sue, fees are high, and forgiven debt may be taxable.
FTC red flags: a company that charges fees before it settles or reduces a debt, guarantees it can make debt disappear, tells you to stop talking to creditors, or promises to stop collection lawsuits. Report scams at ReportFraud.ftc.gov and to your state attorney general.
Large settlement company; fees up to 25% of enrolled debt; read every risk first
Key takeaways
Updated 2026-10-28.
“Debt relief” covers very different services: nonprofit credit counseling and debt management plans, debt settlement, and bankruptcy. The risks and costs differ a lot.
The FTC warns: anyone who charges before settling a debt, or guarantees your debts will be forgiven, is a red flag.
Debt settlement can hurt your credit, may lead to collection lawsuits, and forgiven debt can be taxable. Know the risks before you enroll.
Retirees on a fixed income can often start with a free conversation with creditors or a reputable nonprofit credit counselor.
Our reviews
Pick #1
NFCC (National Foundation for Credit Counseling)
Best place to start
Our rating: Not star-rated. Qualitative award; see Methodology.
Key data (checked 2026-10-28)
Nonprofit network of member credit counseling agencies with accreditation standards
Debt management plans: one monthly payment; 'no hidden fees' per NFCC
Fees for a DMP are set by the member agency and vary by state
Why we chose it
The NFCC helps you find a vetted nonprofit counselor, so it's the safest first call.
Pros
Nonprofit, accredited members
Full budget review
DMPs can lower interest without a new loan
Cons
A DMP usually closes enrolled credit cards
Plans typically take years to complete
Who should skip it
No one. A counseling session is a low-risk first step.
Our rating: Preliminary. Not star-rated; see Methodology.
Key data (checked 2026-10-28)
Debt settlement for unsecured debt (credit cards, medical bills, some personal loans). Not mortgages or car loans
Fees vary by state and debt amount, up to 25% of enrolled debt, charged only after a debt is settled
Company claim: clients who complete the program save about 45% before fees, or 20% including fees, over 24–48 months. Not all clients finish, and not all debts are settled
Says it is BBB-accredited with an A+ rating (company claim)
Settlement can hurt your credit for up to 7 years, creditors may still sue, and forgiven debt may be taxable
Minimum enrolled debt
Why we chose it
If a counselor confirms you can't afford a DMP and you want to avoid bankruptcy, NDR is a large, established settlement company that publishes its fee cap.
Pros
Fee charged only after a settlement (per FTC rule for phone-sold debt relief)
Published fee cap (up to 25%)
Cons
High fees
Serious credit damage while you stop paying creditors
Lawsuit and tax risk
Savings only for clients who finish
Who should skip it
Anyone who can afford a DMP, anyone close to bankruptcy who should talk to a bankruptcy attorney, and anyone with mostly secured debt.
Figures change often. Each row shows the date we checked it; confirm on the provider's site before you decide.
Option
Type
Typical cost
Credit impact
Nonprofit?
Checked
NFCC member agencies
Credit counseling / DMP
Counseling often free; DMP fees vary by state
Lower; cards usually closed
Yes
2026-10-28
MMI
Credit counseling / DMP
Set-up fee + monthly fee (by state, debt level)
Lower; cards closed
Yes
2026-10-28
Apprisen
Credit counseling / DMP
Varies
Lower; cards closed
Yes (501(c)(3))
2026-10-28
National Debt Relief
Debt settlement
Up to 25% of enrolled debt, after settlement
Significant; up to 7 years
No
2026-10-28
How to choose
Debt can feel heavier on a fixed income, and families often find out about a parent’s debt late. There’s legitimate help, but this category also attracts scams. Here’s how to tell the difference.
Know the options.
Talk to creditors directly. Many will agree to a payment plan, especially if you call before an account goes to collections.
Nonprofit credit counseling. A reputable counselor reviews your whole budget, offers free information, and may suggest a debt management plan (DMP), where you make one monthly payment and the agency pays creditors, often at reduced interest.
Debt settlement. A company negotiates to pay creditors less than you owe, usually after you save up money in a dedicated account. It can work for some people, but carries real risks.
Bankruptcy. A legal process with serious long-term effects; talk to a bankruptcy attorney. Pre-filing credit counseling must come from an approved agency.
Understand settlement risks. The FTC notes that many people can’t keep up long enough to finish a program. Settlement companies often tell you to stop paying creditors, so late fees build, credit scores fall, and creditors may sue. Forgiven debt may count as taxable income.
Red flags. Upfront fees before any debt is settled (illegal for debt relief services sold by phone), guarantees that debts will be forgiven, pressure to sign fast, and advice to stop talking to your creditors.
Before you sign: get every promise and fee in writing, ask how employees are paid, check complaints with your state attorney general, and read the contract.
Frequently asked questions
What’s the difference between credit counseling and debt settlement?
Counseling helps you budget and may set up a debt management plan to repay in full at lower interest. Settlement tries to pay less than you owe, with more risk.
Can a debt relief company charge upfront fees?
The FTC says legitimate debt relief companies won’t charge before settling or reducing a debt; for services sold by phone, upfront fees are illegal.
Will debt relief hurt my credit?
Debt settlement often does, especially if you stop paying creditors. A DMP may have a smaller effect.
Is forgiven debt taxable?
It can be. Talk to a tax professional.
Can debt collectors take Social Security?
Federal benefits have special protections from most private creditors, with exceptions.
How do I find a reputable credit counselor?
Look for free information up front, a full budget review, written fees, and no pressure. The U.S. Trustee Program lists agencies approved for pre-bankruptcy counseling.
Where do I report a debt relief scam?
To the FTC at ReportFraud.ftc.gov, and to your state attorney general.
Methodology
We reviewed 4 providers' public pricing, rate, and disclosure pages on 2026-10-28. We don't assign star scores. Each pick gets a qualitative "Best for…" award based on the criteria below, and "Preliminary" marks picks where our research is still thin. Partner or affiliate status plays no role in which providers we pick or how we rank them.
We evaluated providers on:
Service type clearly disclosed (counseling/DMP vs. settlement)
Fee structure: no upfront fees before results, written fee quotes, fee as % of enrolled vs. settled debt
Licensing/accreditation and state availability; nonprofit status where claimed
Transparency on risks: credit impact, collections, taxes, dropout
Complaint and enforcement history (CFPB complaint database, FTC/state actions)
Quality of counseling: full budget review, free educational materials, no pressure
All rates, fees, and terms are shown with the date checked; check current rates before acting. Affiliate relationships do not affect scores.
YouRetire Editorial writes for families planning retirement and care. We use regulator and government sources, show when we last checked data, and don’t let partners buy ratings. Read how we review and our editorial standards.
This guide is educational and not individual financial, tax, insurance, or legal advice.
YouRetire uses essential cookies for security, sessions, and site functionality. With your permission, we may also use cookies to understand site usage and improve retirement planning tools.
